iDroid

As I write this, thousands of idiots across the country are standing in line, waiting to buy the newly-released iPhone 4.  I think one of my friends put it best when he asked rhetorically: "Standing in line for two days to get the new iPhone?  How about spending that time volunteering at a homeless shelter instead?"  He makes a great point.  After all, the same phone will still be available in a week or two when the lines are shorter and less time can be wasted.  Trust me...no matter how early you get your phone, someone will beat you to it, and nobody will care about his/her timely purchase either.



The lack of time management exemplified by these iPhone zealots is overshadowed by their blind faith in Apple's brand.  People who have donated thousands of dollars to Apple and AT&T during the past few years by upgrading their phone three times have only the preachings of their lord and savior Steve Jobs to drive them to the store.  Until recently, almost all of the software upgrades available for the iPhone 3G and iPhone 3GS were also available for the iPhone 2G.  The differences in hardware between the generations were few, and I could easily debate that spending hundreds of dollars per year for a crisper camera, an upgraded GPS or slightly faster networking is a questionable investment.  Still, these early adopters are happy to elbow their way to the Apple Store once again to pay another $300 for a camera on the front of their phone.  Seth Godin would be so proud of the "tribe" of unwavering followers that Apple has built.

At this point, my mobile phone ownership has reached a crossroad.  When the original 2G iPhone was released, I owned a Blackberry Pearl (which I reluctantly upgraded after more than two years on a Treo 650).  There was a significant leap between my incumbent phone and Apple's new release, so I was happy when my company bought me an iPhone.  I am still using that original "silverback" version today.  Since that purchase, I have considered other options, such as the 3G, 3GS and Android fleet, but I have not been swayed until now.  At this point, my antiquated camera, slow networking, and discontinued software upgrade potential (version 4.0 of the iPhone firmware is not available for first generation phones) are causing me to start shopping.

So, as a current iPhone owner, will I simply upgrade to their fourth generation product without considering alternatives?  As with any purchase, I think there are several factors to weigh, and each one is valued differently by each consumer.  For me, the main difference between Droids and iPhones is the quality of the network.  That's it, the rest is clever marketing (except, maybe, for Facetime, but since it only works on WiFi connections amongst iPhone 4 users, Droid will have ample time to catch up soon).  Need a good camera, a plethora of apps, the ability to manage messages and an integrated MP3 player?  Both products are within an arm's reach of each other in all of those areas, especially after Google Music is launched in September.  However, it doesn't matter how cool your phone is if you can't get online, and the AT&T network in the San Francisco Bay Area has become so oversubscribed that it is now a deterrent from marrying oneself to the carrier for another two years.  So, in my personal evaluation of the mobile phone market, the network is the most important differentiator, and Apple's inability to partner with more carriers might be the impetus for me to join the growing marketshare of Droid users.

Overall, my antiquated 2G iPhone is still serving most of my needs (albeit slowly and with spotty AT&T coverage), and I certainly don't feel additional urgency simply because a new version is now available.  I'd rather spend some time volunteering this weekend than standing in line at the mall with the huddled masses of Steve Jobs worshippers.
 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • Trackbacks are closed for this post.
Comments
  • No comments exist for this post.
Leave a comment

Submitted comments are subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Enter the above security code (required)

 Name (required)

 Email (will not be published) (required)

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.